Courts Minister updates Parliament on online Form E problems
1,403 affected cases are still live
The Courts Minister Shailesh Vara has updated the House of Commons on the investigation into the online Form E error which was made public last month.
"[The Form E] fault meant that the automatic calculator in the form calculated the wrong total for an individual's net assets by failing to deduct certain liabilities.
"The Ministry of Justice (MOJ) was alerted to the fault on 10 December 2015 and a corrected version of the form was put online on 14 December. However the wider implications of the faulty form were not immediately recognised.
"As soon as I was made aware of this issue on 16 December, I ordered an urgent investigation.
"The investigation found the faulty formula was present in versions of Form E which were online between April 2014 and mid December 2015 and between April 2011 and January 2012.
"A total of 36,527 cases contain a version of Form E filed from these periods. HMCTS staff have now reviewed all these cases and found that 3,638 files – 10% – contained the faulty calculator version of Form E with an incorrect figure for net assets figure in the summary table.
"1,403 of these cases are still live, allowing HMCTS to intervene immediately to clearly flag these cases to the courts in order to avoid the error affecting the final orders in these cases.
"The remaining 2,235 files – 6.1% – were closed cases. Although the faulty form was used in these cases, it will not necessarily have had any effect on the ultimate outcome. Form E is only a part of the material used by the parties and the court and is used at an early stage, so the information is often disputed or superseded by further information introduced during proceedings.
"Following the error coming to light, HMCTS established a dedicated email address which people could use if they were concerned about their own case: formE@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk . This email address was advertised on our website and also in all responses to media enquiries. As of 21 January, 51 members of the public have emailed us about their case.
"I have instructed HMCTS to write to all parties in the 2,235 closed cases. The letter expresses our sincere regret for the error, sets out what happened and explains that, although Form E is just one part of the evidence used in their case, there remains a possibility that the error affected the final outcome.
"The letter sets out options available to people involved in these cases. Some may wish to do nothing, if, for example, they know that the error was corrected during the proceedings or they do not wish to re-open their cases. If people think they have been affected by this error then they can apply to the court to vary or set aside their order. My officials consulted the President of the Family Division about the court rules and procedures that would apply to such applications or for any other proceedings that might be open to the parties. My officials also consulted the President on the development of a specific form for such applications. We have provided a link to the new form in our letter to the parties, as well as guidance on how to complete the form.
"I have instructed that no court fee will be charged for making this application, and this is also made this clear in the letter from HMCTS.
"We are also uploading a new version of Form E which makes clearer how the calculation of net assets should be made. We will also consider the future of Form E as part of our broader court reforms and the automatic calculator function will be disabled during this process.
"This failure should not have happened. Divorce proceedings can be very difficult and I sincerely apologise for this situation and any distress it may have caused."
Tony Roe, Solicitor and Arbitrator, commented:
"The Ministry of Justice (MOJ) was alerted to the fault on 10 December and a corrected version of the form was put online on 14 December. A circular went out to the judiciary on 18 December. Clearly the scale of the review has taken more time and resources than anyone may have envisaged.
"I am not sure why the Minister says that the wider implications of the faulty form were not immediately recognised. It was obvious to specialist family lawyers.
"Originally, the Rt Hon Michael Gove, Justice Secretary, said that up to 17,000 people might have been affected. That figure now announced is double that.
"The investigation found 36,527 cases contain a version of Form E filed from these periods. HMCTS discovered 3,638 files contained the faulty calculator version of Form E with an incorrect figure for net assets figure in the summary.
"1,403 of these cases are still live so hopefully the issue can be proactively dealt with. The remaining 2,235 files are closed – this is where the real problems could lie – and letters are being sent out to those individuals. Waiving any necessary court fee is one thing but these people will need specialist legal advice over a complex issue and there is no longer legal aid there for them."
21/1/16 (supplemented 22/1/16)