username

password

Established
Berkeley Lifford Hall Accountancy ServicesIQ Legal Training

Home > News

Supreme Court to give judgment on proportionality of care orders

On 15 June the Supreme Court will hand down judgment in Re H-W (Children). The Court will determine whether, when an appellate court reviews a first instance decision concerning the proportionality of orders made under the courts' obligations under the Human Rights Act 1998, it is necessary for the appellate court to undertake its own proportionality assessment of that decision.

The First Appellant, M, is the mother of six children including C, D, E, and F. Following longstanding concerns related to both sexual abuse by their elder brother A and neglect, in March 2020 the local authority issued proceedings seeking to take C, D, and E into its care and place them in three separate foster homes. It also sought that M's newly born child F (daughter of the Second Appellant F3) be removed for adoption.

Following two hearings, Judge McPhee found that E had been sexually assaulted by her brother, A, and that M and F3 had both failed to protect the children from sexual abuse and delayed reporting the assault. Judge McPhee ultimately concluded that it would not be safe for C, D, and E to remain in the care of M and F3 and therefore made the care orders sought. A final decision in respect of F was postponed.

The First Appellant appealed to the Court of Appeal, which by a two to one majority decision dismissed the appeal. The judgment is reported as H-W (Children: Proportionality) [2021] EWCA Civ 1451. For a summary of the Court of Appeal judgment, click here.

12/6/22